5 Comments
User's avatar
John McGill's avatar

As a counter thought, would it be right for players that haven't played in the qualifying games being eligble for the final? Does having no qualification make the Shield prone to a team winning with an asterisk (if it hasn't already in the past)?

The AFL can allow a player on a list to play without playing a game (think Marlion Pickett) but as the Shield is essentially treated as Test Reserve grade should it adopt a policy more in line with club cricket where the 3s side can't be stacked?

Expand full comment
Peter Lalor's avatar

It’s a good point John. Mitch has barely played for WA in recent years and Cam’s been absent on national duties. It would be unfair on those who missed out to some degree, but so much better for the competition to have the big names playing. It’s a step too far to block cricketers from IPL totally but surely asking them to miss a couple of games because of a First Class final is not too much to ask.

Expand full comment
Dennis Coon's avatar

For me the footy season doesn't start until the Shield Final is decided.

Expand full comment
Damian Zito's avatar

Great to see your writings here

Expand full comment
S.Pickled's avatar

You’ve had this one up your sleeve for a minute ay Pete 😂

Expand full comment