14 Comments
User's avatar
Andrew Faulkner's avatar

Oasis 10 votes, Joy Division 2 votes, is not a great recommendation for the press box's collective taste.

Gideon Haigh's avatar

I am quite impressed that Elbow got two.

Marcus Woodfield's avatar

Agree on that. Oasis have no business being above Joy Division, New Order or The Smiths

Evan Willis's avatar

It is a pleasure maintaining this playlist Gideon, glad that it is bringing others joy

Sriram Dayanand's avatar

A few weeks ago, I saw this local band who have been a cover band of The Fall for 20 years or so (there was a Joy Division and a New Order cover band on the bill too)

Mr. Pharmacist were quite excellent - found a couple of videos of them:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D3qlY3GGQJQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jt-Ilri77CM

Gideon Haigh's avatar

That's made my day, Sriram. My appreciation of Canada grows all the time.

Sriram Dayanand's avatar

I find it amazing that they have built up a local cult following by playing just The Fall. The venue was rammed packed to the gills. They are soooo local...don't travel far. Just the Toronto and immediate local areas.

I took a couple of people who had never heard of The Fall (and my Welsh mate who is a fanatic anyways) and the newbies had their jaws on the floor. They just fucking loved it. They did not know a single song but walked out in a daze. (Of course, I had to explain the name of the band before over beers in the pub)

Gareth Swarbrick's avatar

Killdozer’s Knuckles the Dog shares a tune with the Sisters of Mercy’s Some Kind of Stranger. Have a listen.

Gideon Haigh's avatar

True dat. Except that SOM string their song out for seven interminable minutes.

Sriram Dayanand's avatar

And this of them doing "Mr.Pharmacist" - quite good they are in this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZ1vJ6HeHkg

Keith Knight's avatar

Where are Van Der Graaf Generator on that Manchester bands list?

Killdozer's live version of 'American Pie' (both sides) was something to be at. And I was quoting the lyrics to 'Lupus' to a friend only the other day.

James Welham's avatar

Not seeing a single vote for New Order is distressing.

Geoff Hyde's avatar

Do you know John Otway? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dyFa70qIDwk. Hold's the WR for most live gigs. Eccentricly brilliant in all aspects - music, lyrics, theatre, slapstick comedy, political and social commentary. I saw him in London in 1985 just after watching Border making 196 at Lords. Just a superb day! I returned many times to London just to watch him, always live in a smallish local pub, just brilliant entertainment.