14 Comments
User's avatar
Andrew Faulkner's avatar

Oasis 10 votes, Joy Division 2 votes, is not a great recommendation for the press box's collective taste.

Expand full comment
Gideon Haigh's avatar

I am quite impressed that Elbow got two.

Expand full comment
Marcus Woodfield's avatar

Agree on that. Oasis have no business being above Joy Division, New Order or The Smiths

Expand full comment
Evan Willis's avatar

It is a pleasure maintaining this playlist Gideon, glad that it is bringing others joy

Expand full comment
Sriram Dayanand's avatar

A few weeks ago, I saw this local band who have been a cover band of The Fall for 20 years or so (there was a Joy Division and a New Order cover band on the bill too)

Mr. Pharmacist were quite excellent - found a couple of videos of them:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D3qlY3GGQJQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jt-Ilri77CM

Expand full comment
Gideon Haigh's avatar

That's made my day, Sriram. My appreciation of Canada grows all the time.

Expand full comment
Sriram Dayanand's avatar

I find it amazing that they have built up a local cult following by playing just The Fall. The venue was rammed packed to the gills. They are soooo local...don't travel far. Just the Toronto and immediate local areas.

I took a couple of people who had never heard of The Fall (and my Welsh mate who is a fanatic anyways) and the newbies had their jaws on the floor. They just fucking loved it. They did not know a single song but walked out in a daze. (Of course, I had to explain the name of the band before over beers in the pub)

Expand full comment
Gideon Haigh's avatar

There is also The Extricated.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brix_%26_the_Extricated

Expand full comment
Gareth Swarbrick's avatar

Killdozer’s Knuckles the Dog shares a tune with the Sisters of Mercy’s Some Kind of Stranger. Have a listen.

Expand full comment
Gideon Haigh's avatar

True dat. Except that SOM string their song out for seven interminable minutes.

Expand full comment
Sriram Dayanand's avatar

And this of them doing "Mr.Pharmacist" - quite good they are in this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZ1vJ6HeHkg

Expand full comment
Keith Knight's avatar

Where are Van Der Graaf Generator on that Manchester bands list?

Killdozer's live version of 'American Pie' (both sides) was something to be at. And I was quoting the lyrics to 'Lupus' to a friend only the other day.

Expand full comment
James Welham's avatar

Not seeing a single vote for New Order is distressing.

Expand full comment
Geoff Hyde's avatar

Do you know John Otway? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dyFa70qIDwk. Hold's the WR for most live gigs. Eccentricly brilliant in all aspects - music, lyrics, theatre, slapstick comedy, political and social commentary. I saw him in London in 1985 just after watching Border making 196 at Lords. Just a superb day! I returned many times to London just to watch him, always live in a smallish local pub, just brilliant entertainment.

Expand full comment